Comments on: Atrocity and Memory http://www.david-campbell.org Photography, Multimedia, Politics Tue, 17 Jan 2012 23:50:34 +0000 hourly 1 http://wordpress.org/?v=3.3.1 By: Atrocity and Memory | Bijash Chauhan http://www.david-campbell.org/photography/atrocity-and-memory/#comment-29873 Atrocity and Memory | Bijash Chauhan Thu, 18 Aug 2011 12:38:15 +0000 http://www.david-campbell.org/?page_id=76#comment-29873 [...] http://www.david-campbell.org/photography/atrocity-and-memory/ [...] [...] http://www.david-campbell.org/photography/atrocity-and-memory/ [...]

]]> By: Atrocity pictures http://www.david-campbell.org/photography/atrocity-and-memory/#comment-29869 Atrocity pictures Wed, 17 Aug 2011 12:37:52 +0000 http://www.david-campbell.org/?page_id=76#comment-29869 [...] Atrocity and Memory | David Campbell Among the many images of atrocity that emerged from the Bosnian War, the picture of Fikret Alic and others imprisoned … [...] [...] Atrocity and Memory | David Campbell Among the many images of atrocity that emerged from the Bosnian War, the picture of Fikret Alic and others imprisoned … [...]

]]> By: The Back Catalogue (3): Images of atrocity, conflict and war | David Campbell http://www.david-campbell.org/photography/atrocity-and-memory/#comment-28205 The Back Catalogue (3): Images of atrocity, conflict and war | David Campbell Mon, 13 Jun 2011 12:19:33 +0000 http://www.david-campbell.org/?page_id=76#comment-28205 [...] workGuidePhotographyAtrocity and MemoryVideosHIV/AIDSImaging FamineVideosGrantsMultimediaThe Boarding HouseLiving in the [...] [...] workGuidePhotographyAtrocity and MemoryVideosHIV/AIDSImaging FamineVideosGrantsMultimediaThe Boarding HouseLiving in the [...]

]]> By: Thinking Images v.18: Ratko Mladic and the limits of visibility | David Campbell http://www.david-campbell.org/photography/atrocity-and-memory/#comment-28187 Thinking Images v.18: Ratko Mladic and the limits of visibility | David Campbell Mon, 13 Jun 2011 09:05:04 +0000 http://www.david-campbell.org/?page_id=76#comment-28187 [...] workGuidePhotographyAtrocity and MemoryVideosHIV/AIDSImaging FamineVideosGrantsMultimediaThe Boarding HouseLiving in the [...] [...] workGuidePhotographyAtrocity and MemoryVideosHIV/AIDSImaging FamineVideosGrantsMultimediaThe Boarding HouseLiving in the [...]

]]> By: Holocaust analogies help no one | Duncan Edward Robinson http://www.david-campbell.org/photography/atrocity-and-memory/#comment-13626 Holocaust analogies help no one | Duncan Edward Robinson Fri, 29 Oct 2010 15:27:19 +0000 http://www.david-campbell.org/?page_id=76#comment-13626 [...] photo of the skeletal Fikret Alic behind barbed wire evoked the iconic images of the Holocaust and created hysteria in the world’s media. The fact that Bosnia’s concentration camps were a unique horror was ignored. Rather than [...] [...] photo of the skeletal Fikret Alic behind barbed wire evoked the iconic images of the Holocaust and created hysteria in the world’s media. The fact that Bosnia’s concentration camps were a unique horror was ignored. Rather than [...]

]]> By: Owen http://www.david-campbell.org/photography/atrocity-and-memory/#comment-6876 Owen Thu, 03 Jun 2010 08:53:46 +0000 http://www.david-campbell.org/?page_id=76#comment-6876 David, Roger Lippman has referred to "Atrocity, Memory, Photography" in "A Critical Chomsky Reader" (link in previous post). Although I didn't refer specifically to it in my own contribution, in which I describe the outcome of my investigation of the LM claims, I want to express my appreciation to you for it once again. The two moments when all the individual pieces of information I had found confirming my doubts came together were when I read your essay and when I attended a talk by Kemal. Your rigorous, intelligent analysis and the transparent truth of Kemal's testimony to his personal experience left no room for any lingering doubt about which side of the debate was informed by intellectual and personal honesty. Have you seen the interview Fikret Alic gave to the Bosnian television programme 60 Minuta? It's at YouTube - http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=W2sO-XcI9FQ (English subtitles) David, Roger Lippman has referred to “Atrocity, Memory, Photography” in “A Critical Chomsky Reader” (link in previous post). Although I didn’t refer specifically to it in my own contribution, in which I describe the outcome of my investigation of the LM claims, I want to express my appreciation to you for it once again. The two moments when all the individual pieces of information I had found confirming my doubts came together were when I read your essay and when I attended a talk by Kemal. Your rigorous, intelligent analysis and the transparent truth of Kemal’s testimony to his personal experience left no room for any lingering doubt about which side of the debate was informed by intellectual and personal honesty.

Have you seen the interview Fikret Alic gave to the Bosnian television programme 60 Minuta? It’s at YouTube – http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=W2sO-XcI9FQ (English subtitles)

]]> By: A Critical Chomsky Reader « Untitled http://www.david-campbell.org/photography/atrocity-and-memory/#comment-6764 A Critical Chomsky Reader « Untitled Sun, 30 May 2010 08:23:13 +0000 http://www.david-campbell.org/?page_id=76#comment-6764 [...] David Campbell’s e-mail exchange with Chomsky, which links to Campbell’s detailed study of the concentration camps in Bosnia, “Atrocity, Memory, [...] [...] David Campbell’s e-mail exchange with Chomsky, which links to Campbell’s detailed study of the concentration camps in Bosnia, “Atrocity, Memory, [...]

]]> By: David Campbell http://www.david-campbell.org/photography/atrocity-and-memory/#comment-4698 David Campbell Sun, 21 Feb 2010 15:27:40 +0000 http://www.david-campbell.org/?page_id=76#comment-4698 Mr D'Adamo - your comment is full of the very bigotry you supposedly object to. I find it objectionable on many counts, but have posted it as a reminder to myself and others about the toxic views people like yourself hold. Your prejudice is unsupported by any evidence and unrelated to the specific concern of my research in "Atrocity and Memory." Casting the issue as one of 'Christian' vs 'Muslim' is to betray a considerable ignorance about the identities at stake in the Bosnian War, as is the suggestion that all participants were equally culpable. Mr D’Adamo – your comment is full of the very bigotry you supposedly object to. I find it objectionable on many counts, but have posted it as a reminder to myself and others about the toxic views people like yourself hold. Your prejudice is unsupported by any evidence and unrelated to the specific concern of my research in “Atrocity and Memory.” Casting the issue as one of ‘Christian’ vs ‘Muslim’ is to betray a considerable ignorance about the identities at stake in the Bosnian War, as is the suggestion that all participants were equally culpable.

]]> By: Mr. D'Adamo http://www.david-campbell.org/photography/atrocity-and-memory/#comment-4668 Mr. D'Adamo Sat, 20 Feb 2010 03:16:54 +0000 http://www.david-campbell.org/?page_id=76#comment-4668 Mr. Campbell, there is no denying that atrocities were committed by the Serbs however the atrocities committed by the Muslims were just as and if not greater. The targeting of the innocent based on there christian beliefs fueled there savagery. The Muslims whom we have seen based on post 911 and throughout history dictates that they are unwilling to allow the freedom of religion. It is either there way or no other. In viewing some horrific photo's there's was the use of sole sectarian use of wholesale terror based on christian beliefs. The UN, and others view only the Serbs as being worthy of war crimes. It is my belief that the Muslims are just as guilty if not more and are undeserving of any further legitimized treatment. Tell me Mr. Campbell what is the true intent of the Mujaheddin, who called upon Jihad and the christian who must be destroyed. Mr. Campbell, there is no denying that atrocities were committed by the Serbs however the atrocities committed by the Muslims were just as and if not greater. The targeting of the innocent based on there christian beliefs fueled there savagery. The Muslims whom we have seen based on post 911 and throughout history dictates that they are unwilling to allow the freedom of religion. It is either there way or no other. In viewing some horrific photo’s there’s was the use of sole sectarian use of wholesale terror based on christian beliefs. The UN, and others view only the Serbs as being worthy of war crimes. It is my belief that the Muslims are just as guilty if not more and are undeserving of any further legitimized treatment. Tell me Mr. Campbell what is the true intent of the Mujaheddin, who called upon Jihad and the christian who must be destroyed.

]]> By: The fundamentalist defence of Chomsky on Bosnia | David Campbell -- Photography, Multimedia, Politics http://www.david-campbell.org/photography/atrocity-and-memory/#comment-2859 The fundamentalist defence of Chomsky on Bosnia | David Campbell -- Photography, Multimedia, Politics Fri, 27 Nov 2009 18:33:31 +0000 http://www.david-campbell.org/?page_id=76#comment-2859 [...] because they simply recycle the discredited Thomas Deichmann and Philip Knightly allegations. My original 2002 investigation picked those apart, so trying to debate the likes of Herman and Petersen is largely pointless because of the way they [...] [...] because they simply recycle the discredited Thomas Deichmann and Philip Knightly allegations. My original 2002 investigation picked those apart, so trying to debate the likes of Herman and Petersen is largely pointless because of the way they [...]

]]>